TGM National Headlines – May 29th
National headlines
- Environment Minister Jim Prentice announced that Canada would not start restricting emissions until at least 2012. Also, the province of Ontario has announced that it will join Quebec and BC in creating a cap-and-trade system to curb emissions.
- A progressive new green roof policy has been approved in Toronto by an overwhelming majority.
- Canada’s Governor-General Michaelle Jean added to the seal hunt controversy by eating raw seal meat.
- The government of Canada will be selling off the nuclear production wing of the Atomic Energy Agency of Canada.
- City Hall in Toronto announced the approval of the first major dedicated bike lane.
- Communities in the Northwest Territories have announced unanimous opposition to the Alberta tar sands, based on worry over the potential health effects.
- A new American study confirms that a large portion of the world’s remaining oil and gas reserves are under the Arctic.
- The Canadian National Railway has paid $1.8 million as a settlement to two small communities devastated by derailments in 2005.
International headlines
- US cap-and-trade bill passes House Committee
- China to boost renewable energy
- Northeastern North America more likely to feel effects of greenland ice melt
- Good year for North Atlantic right whales
NATIONAL HEADLINES
Environment Minister Jim Prentice announced that Canada would not start restricting emissions until at least 2012.
CHRIS BERUBE: A couple of big announcements this week about Canada’s attempts to lower emissions. First, federal environment minister Jim Prentice announced that Canada will not be requiring industrial pollutants to reduce emissions until 2012, so as to harmonize the American plans, which are not going to call for major cuts to be fully implemented for another six years. The American plan, announced in the Waxman-Markey Act, will be discussed later in the program. However, one of the major tenets of the plan is that the most substantial cuts to GHG emissions won’t take place until the end of 2015. Prentice announced that Canada will follow suit to keep harmonized with the US. Originally, the Conservative government had announced that a bold new plan for emission cuts was scheduled to take effect in early 2010. This new announcement ensures that nothing will be done on that front for two more years. Prentice said that the government plans to spend the extra two years planning on a post-Kyoto framework to reduce emissions. While the federal government announced that it would be delaying major new actions this week, the provinces announced their own plans to become more proactive than ever before. The the Ontario government announced this week that they plan to implement a new cap-and-trade system to address emission reductions. It will join Quebec and BC in a new trading system that the provinces are describing as a “bandaid” solution until a full North American trading system can be put into place. Said McGuinty, “we can’t wait until Washington or Ottawa take action any longer – we have to move ahead”. Quebec introduced legislation that would create a cap-and-trade system on industrial polluters by 2012, while BC has been discussing the option extensively before the provincial election. The Ontario proposal suggests that the province try and fall in line with this same timeline. While McGuinty insisted that Ontario would fall into line with new standards, he refused to say whether old coal-fired power plants, the provinces worst polluters, would face bigger penalty. As it stands, coal fire plants are not expected to be closed until 2014. We’ll have more on Ontario’s plans for a cap-and-trade pollution system as the story develops. [ index ]
A progressive new green roof policy has been approved in Toronto by an overwhelming majority.
DARYN CAISTER: A progressive new green roof policy has been approved in Toronto by an overwhelming majority. The proposed green roof policy for the city was voted in this week by a vote of 36-2, with only councillors Doug Holyday and Rob Ford voting against the new rules. The plan will become the most comprehensive in North America to date by increasing the amount of rooftop greenery required on Toronto buildings as well as increasing the number of buildings that will fall under the regulations. Green Roofs for Healthy cities, an independent policy advocate group are reporting that while the new rules put Toronto on top as far as policy, in 2008 Toronto didn’t even place in the top 10 in North America as far as actual green space. The group also emphasized that while the rules are a good start that its importance will be measured by its implementation which has yet to be seen. New residential buildings constructed after January 31 2010 with at least 2000 square meters will be subject with the new policy, which is much tougher than the original 5000 square meter minimum to fall under the policy that was proposed by city staff. Industrial buildings will also be given until January 31 2011 to comply by having 10%, or 2000 square meters, whichever is less set aside for green space. While some environmental critics, including some of the city councillors were hoping for even tougher rules, Deputy mayor Joe Pantalone noted during the voting that roof’s make up about 21% of Toronto’s surface area making the case for potentially significant impacts from any green roof policy. The new green space should help reduce the energy load required to cool buildings during the summer and also conserve rainfall in addition to the aesthetic improvements from the gardens. [ index ]
Canada’s Governor-General Michaelle Jean added to the seal hunt controversy by eating raw seal meat.
DARYN CAISTER: Canada’s Governor-General Michaelle Jean added to the seal hunt controversy by eating raw seal meat. Michaelle Jean was in Nunavut this week to take part in a traditional Inuit feast in part to continue to show her support for Inuit traditions and culture. The Canadian press published photos of Ms. Jean assisting the mayor of Rankin Inlet skin a seal as part of the Inuit celebration before eating the seal’s raw heart. Mr. Hickes, the mayor of Rankin Inlet described to the press that she had brought a message of hope with her support to the young people of the community by participating in the celebration. Aside from the graphic descriptions of the ritual the Canadian press has published, the move also helped to further enflaming opponents of the annual seal hunt such as animal rights activists and international media from the European Union where the seal hunt has been a sore issue for some time. The Governor-General, has demonstrated however that she is unafraid of controversy, and with her likely in her final year in the position she seems as determined as ever to stand up for what she sees as fundamental aboriginal rights to their traditions. When asked if her actions were directed at making a statement towards Europe and the recently proposed ban on seal products she responded simply for people to quote “Take from that what you will”. [ index ]
The government of Canada will be selling off the nuclear production wing of the Atomic Energy Agency of Canada.
CHRIS BERUBE: Last week on the program we quickly discussed the emergency shuttering of one of the reactors at the Chalk River nuclear facility in Ontario due to safety concerns. This week, the extent of the damage was revealed – it turns out that Chalk River needs to be closed for three months according to a new report by the Atomic Energy Agency of Canada. The Chalk River reactor was decomissioned after it was revealed that it had been leaking heavy water two weeks ago. Some officials in the Agency said the media earlier this week that it was within the realm of possibility that reactor could remain shuttered as long as eight months if they can’t find a safe way to stop the leaks, though those statements have since been withdrawn. The announcement came in a week where much happened regarding the future of Canada’s nuclear energy supply – earlier in the week, the Harper government had announced plans to privatize the nucelar energy wing of Atomic Energy Agency of Canada Ltd. The government said that is specifically wants to find a private owner for the crown corporation, responsible for the country’s nuclear safety and much of its nuclear production, because it thinks that private owners would be better for dealing with the complicated reactors like those at Chalk River. Natural Resources Minister Lisa Raitt said that the move was intended to strengthen the company, and that the government will probably end up having to hold onto the shut down NRU reactor at Chalk River, at least until they can assure that it is safe to use again. In her announcement, minister Raitt emphasized that the government was going to be trying to comply with G8 plans to safely expand to use of nuclear power to move away from other emissions producing sources. Environmentalists roundly criticized the government, warning that private owner would do nothing to ensure that nuclear reactors were more safe. Some groups, including Greenpeace Canada, came out warning that such a sale might even lead to more accidents like that seen at Chalk River. [ index ]
City Hall in Toronto announced the approval of the first major dedicated bike lane.
DARYN CAISTER: City Hall in Toronto announced the approval of the first major dedicated bike lane. The Jarvis St. bike lane will remove the reversible direction centre lane to make way for a series of street improvements along the street including the bike lane. The lanes are estimated to cost about $50,000 to $100,000 of the total estimated $6.3 million for the project. The new revamped Jarvis St. was passed with a 28-16 vote by city council after a full day debate including many members of the public who showed up to city hall to observe the meeting wearing bike helmets. Bike lanes have increasingly become a city wide issue, described by Toronto media as a war between cyclists and motorists as the city pushes ahead with a highly controversial trans-city bike corridor across Bloor St. and Danforth Avenue. The main battle over the bike lanes comes from cyclists group’s who insist that bike use is restricted in the city as a main mode of transportation by the lack of safe routes. Meanwhile various businesses and business improvement groups fear the new lanes will reduce parking and business for all the affected streets by removing valuable street parking that is already considered inadequate. Toronto Mayor David Miller started off the debate this week by calling on motorists to accept minimal transit time increases which is estimated to be only a couple minutes in most areas for the sake of providing safety to the cities many bike commuters. Plans to begin the adjustments for the Jarvis section are to start construction immediately, which there is still no date set for a vote on the various other bike lane plans, some of which require some level of provincial approval. [ index ]
Communities in the Northwest Territories have announced unanimous opposition to the Alberta tar sands, based on worry over the potential health effects.
CHRIS BERUBE: With more disturbing statistical evidence about the damage wrought by the oil extraction in Alberta, communities in the Northwest Territories are banding together to fight the tar sands. The NWT Associate of Communities, which represents 33 townships in the territory, voted unanimously to wage an attack against the Alberta tar sands due to the damage done to the Athabasca River that caused deformities in fish. The Association justified their formal fight against the tar sands by saying that the tar sands no longer forms a risk to only Alberta, but to everyone along the Alberta basin. The resolution passed calls for a moratorium on new tar sands development until it can be promised that all water coming downstream to the territories is clean. Most Northwest Territories rivers are downstream from the tar sands development. Kevin Kennedy, who is a Yellowknife city councillor justified the unanimous vote by saying that “Everyone is concerned because we are hearing all kinds of stories from Fort Chipewyan about human health problems and are concerned with the health of the Northwest Territories as a whole.” Fort Chipewyan has perhaps faced the worst consequences from the tar sands byproduct, as a recent study found that residents there have cancer rates several times higher than the national average. The government of Alberta, for its part, has thus far rejected entreties from the territories to build a filtration system for water coming from the tar sands, saying they are not responsible for transboundary issues. [ index ]
A new American study confirms that a large portion of the world’s remaining oil and gas reserves are under the Arctic.
DARYN CAISTER: A new American study confirms that a large portion of the world’s remaining oil and gas reserves are under the Arctic. The US Geological Survey report said that 13% of the world’s remaining undiscovered oil reserves, and as much as 30% of the remaining natural gas deposits are under the increasingly disputed Arctic territory. The new figures raise the amount of estimated undiscovered reserves in the north just as territory disputes between Canada, Russia, France and other countries continue to escalate. The report, which was published in the journal “Science”, says that as much as 80 million barrels of oil is hidden under the Arctic shelf. The report estimated that the discovery would not be large enough to make any significant increase in availability to what is already a rapidly declining resource in many parts of the world. The new estimates for natural gas deposits are also expected to increase the push for natural gas pipelines from the Mackenzie Delta and north shore of Alaska and Canada to the US. The report identified that while substantial deposits exist on Canadian and US territory the undiscovered natural gas deposits are concentrated within Russian territory. This is likely to increase tensions between Canada and Russia after Foreign Affairs Minister Lawrence Cannon issued a warning to Russia that Canada would not be intimidated into ceding sovereignty in the North following revelations that Russia had dedicated a unique military force to defend its Arctic claims. Despite motions by the US since president Obama took office to move towards more green energy and the first signs of compliance coming from Canada in recent weeks, this issue is likely to continue to fuel international tensions over resources as the world economy continues to decline. [ index ]
The Canadian National Railway has paid $1.8 million as a settlement to two small communities devastated by derailments in 2005.
CHRIS BERUBE: And in brief this week, Canadian National Railway has finally settled over two derailments in 2005 that devestated small communities in western Canada. CN has agreed to pay $1.8 million to claimants over the derailments that fouled Alberta’s lake Wabamum and killed the once flourishing fish population Cheakamus River in British Columbia. About $1.65-million of the settlement payment will go to environmental and emergency response programs in Alberta and British Columbia, with the remainder going to fines levied under federal and provincial environmental regulations. CN has also committed to putting $2 million towards a cleanup fund for future spills. This is the second largest settlement CN has paid in the last ten years for such a spill. [ index ]
INTERNATIONAL HEADLINES
US cap-and-trade bill passes House Committee
TYLER IRVING: Last week, the American Clean Energy and Security Act was passed by the US House of Representatives Energy and Commerce Committee. Also know as Waxman-Markey after its Democratic drafters, the 932-page bill sets out a cap-and-trade system for regulating carbon emissions. It aims to cut emissions to 17% below 2005 levels by 2020.
The bill has elicited mixed reaction among environmentalists, world leaders, and lawmakers. Some (including UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon) feel that the 17% target does not go far enough, especially compared to more ambitious targets being offered by members of the European Union. Others criticise the complexity of the bill and the fact that most of the tradable permits will initially be given away for free, rather than auctioned off to the highest bidder. On the other side, supporters point out that a stronger bill might not have passed the committee, and that it is crucial for the US to set an example ahead of the UN Summit on Climate Change in Copenhagen this December.
The bill must still face votes in front of the full House of Representative and the Senate. It is unclear whether it will become law by the end of the year. [ index ]
China to boost renewable energy
TYLER IRVING: According to an Agence France-Presse report, China is planning to invest the equivalent of $440 billion US dollars in its renewable energy sector. The report quoted a State Energy Administration official who said that the plan will be submitted to the State Council and will take advantage of funds earmarked to stimulate the Chinese economy.
China rivals the US for top place among the world’s largest emitters of greenhouse gases; taken together, the two countries account for about 40% of global emissions. One major culprit is coal plants: 70% of China’s energy comes from coal and new plants are being built at the rate of one every month. According to a May 10 New York Times article, China now uses more coal than the United States, Europe and Japan combined. Renewables (not including hydroelectricity) make up only 1.5% of China’s energy mix.
China’s Energy Administration would like to see that number expand to 6% by 2020. Part of that goal could be realized by the new massive investment, which is expected to centre largely on wind and solar energy. China is currently the world’s largest producer of solar panels, although most of these are exported. With a drop in profits caused by the global recession, these companies are clamouring for government support. The new stimulus may be just what they need. [ index ]
Northeastern North America more likely to feel effects of Greenland ice melt
TYLER IRVING: A new study by the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder Colorado predicts the consequences melting ice sheets in Greenland could be worse for cities like New York and Boston than other places around the world.
The research was published this week in the journal Geophysical Letters, and was based on runoff data from Greenland and an analysis of ocean circulation patterns. Currently, the melt rate from Greenland’s ice sheet is increasing at a rate of 7% each year. If that trend continues, the resulting addition of fresh water could disrupt ocean currents, sending extra water toward northeastern US states and maritime Canada. That scenario could result in a sea level rise of anywhere from 1 to 1.5 feet by 2100. This would be on top of the overall sea level rise of 1-2 feet predicted by the International Panel on Climate Change. The IPCC’s model largely ignored the effects of melting glaciers.
Although oceanic and atmospheric modelling is notoriously difficult, the predictions underline the fact that the effects of climate change will not be evenly distributed. [ index ]
Good year for North Atlantic right whales
TYLER IRVING: This year, researchers monitoring North Atlantic Right whales in their birthing grounds off the coast of Georgia and Florida recorded 39 new calves. This tops the previous record of 31, set in 2001. As well, a separate group of researchers from Oregon State University and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration detected whale vocalizations off Cape Farewell Sound in Greenland, an area where the whales were previously thought to be extinct.
North Atlantic Right whales once numbered in the thousands, but were favourite targets of hunters since whaling began. This was due to their slow swimming speed and the fact that they contained so much blubber they often continued to float after being killed. By the time hunting was banned in the late 1930s, only a few hundred animals were left in the wild. Today that number is still thought to be less than 400, underscoring the importance of the each new animal detected.
It remains to be seen whether the whales detected off Greenland are a new population or strays from further south, and the new whales born this year won’t reach sexual maturity until at least 2016. Still, scientists are encouraged by the findings, and hope that through conservation this critically endangered species can survive into the future. [ index ]

